Asia, Explore + Roam
comments 5

singapore diaries (iii)

Back already, in Singapore, a place that now feels so familiar I barely notice its idiosyncracies. Such as this: more than eighty per cent of Singaporeans live in HDB flats, owned by the government’s Housing Development Board, like these.

Dizzyingly tall high-rises painted in tropical shades that catch the sun, designed with walkability, shade, diversity and greenery in mind. The policy was introduced in the 1960s as the newly independent city-state searched for a drastic solution to its burgeoning economy and growing population. Workers were moved from cramped shophouses and crumbling shacks to their new homes in the sky. Today the flats are so in demand a three to four year waiting period applies.

It’s a policy idea so drastic – and yet so simple – that it’s unthinkable of it happening at home. And would we want it to? Solve the housing crisis, commit to high-rise living and end accommodation inequality, but lose the green belt, succumb to uniformity and bid farewell to an individual’s right to choose one’s home (if one can afford it)? Imagine if, tomorrow, Theresa May announced plans to tear down older, low-rise housing estates and build thousands of uniform tower blocks in their place? You might argue it was tried and failed, in the Brutalist post-war housing blocks that dot the skyline of London and other British cities. But these were arguably just quick-fixes, constructed in haste with little thought for liveability and longevity, to fill the ruins of blitzkrieged bombsites. Further government-built high rises are unlikely, anyway, after the tragedy of Grenfell Tower.

Singapore’s towers, in utter contrast, are immaculately maintained, always freshly painted, surrounded by rain trees that shade the public walkways and soften the angular edges of these concrete titans. Each estate is essentially a self-sufficient village, with its own convenience store, communal roof garden, food court, doctor’s surgery and sporting facilities. Flats are allocated so that the demographic make-up of each block mirrors the racial make-up of the city as a whole. For a nation with quasi one-party rule, it’s remarkably progressive.

But, as almost always, there are no easy answers. Many have criticised the policy for its narrow focus on the nuclear family. Unmarried adult children do not qualify for their own HDB flat until they turn thirty-five – or get married. HDB sham marriages, it’s rumoured, abound. Still, it’s hard to imagine in our age of austerity back home a government investing so much into public housing. Mostly, I approach HDB flats with an air of ambivalence, appreciating their giraffe-like height and green spaces from an outsider’s perspective, fascinated by the level of meticulous planning involved, but seeing them as a uniquely Singaporean phenomenon. Something that wouldn’t work back home. Regardless, this is my favourite thing of discovering new, faraway places – the opportunity to see how others live, to weigh the alternatives, to wedge open the door to new ways of thinking and living, to contemplate for a brief moment a very different life.

(photos) on digital | Outram and Tiong Bahru | October 2017

Save

Save

Save

  • Are you in Singapore now? To think that we might walked past each other and didn’t even realize it! hhaaa. Would be great to meet you in person.

    Yes, a lot of my Singaporean friends have mixed feeling about HDB housing – which tied up to their CPF. It’s the percentage of your monthly salary that’s getting cut automatically by the gov if you’re Singaporean that goes to your HDB fund and retirement fund. In one hand you’re automatically savings for your future, but at the same time you don’t have the access to use your money as you would like it.

    • Hiya 🙂 Yes, I was in Singapore then! My parents live on the south coast. Whereabouts are you? Keep an eye out for a very pale, blond girl looking like she’s about to melt in the heat 😉

      Very interesting to hear your HDB thoughts. It’s a thorny topic, I think, and difficult that’s there no opt-out. It’s fascinating to see how different states approach the issue of housing, especially given the housing crisis we have in my home country of Britain. Did you grow up in Singapore?

      • Hahaha,
        I’m around north east side, but most of the time I will be around the central area. I didn’t grow up in Singapore, but working here do really give me a lot of insights. Let me know when you’re around and if you’re up for a coffee!

  • Love that first photo! // I only just learned about HDB flats this past summer when my Singaporean friend was jokingly telling me why her mom was so urgent about marrying her off! -Audrey | Brunch at Audrey’s

    • Man, that’s pretty crazy. I think in theory the policy is a great idea but the limits placed on it seem quite old-fashioned! Thanks for sharing your thoughts 🙂